Plenty of annoying skinny (including me!) or even not-skinny people have snarked about their “physics diet“: energy out matches energy in. Perhaps a bad way of thinking about the issue, at least if you believe Robert Lustig. The hormones insulin and leptin regulate weight, and are responsible for both energy efficiency (you might be surprised by rest energy expenditure) and feelings of satiation vs hunger. In obese people, insulin suppresses the effect of leptin to ensure increased energy intake & retention (conversely, by suppressing insulin in the obese the weight “plateau” from the starvation response is avoided). Why did we evolve that? Lustig hypothesizes that in puberty & pregnancy such an effect is desirable. Hat-tip to Modeled Behavior, who probably linked the study before without my bothering to read it.
Elsewhere (more specifically, at the Mises blog), an actual physicist (or at least aspiring physicist) sticks up for Austrian epistemology by attacking Milton Friedman’s “positive economics”. However, a number of commenters point out errors you really would not have expected a physicist not to make.
Finally, I can’t tie this into physics at all, but while looking for the previous link, I discovered that the creator of Sita Sings the Blues (which I think was nominated for an Oscar or something) is anti-copyright and made the movie freely available. I’m watching it right now, which is a much for gratifying experience than having my browser repeatedly crash trying to play the DivX for “McCabe & Mrs Miller”.
February 15, 2010 at 11:42 pm
“Paradoxical” consequences of physics shouldn’t come as a surprise, though the basic laws are kinda trivial the world is full of entangled feedback loops, positive and negative, and thinking about it in terms of lumps of stuff and money shuffled around (like economists do…) is borderline cretinous.
February 16, 2010 at 7:49 am
Man, just rent McCabe and Mrs. Miller! It’s a brilliant film!
February 16, 2010 at 7:50 am
Stephen Kinsella is, however, a swine.
February 16, 2010 at 8:04 am
16.99! Just buy it now at Amazon! Or rent it. IT IS THE GREATEST MOVIE EVAHS.
http://www.amazon.com/McCabe-Mrs-Miller-Warren-Beatty/dp/B000063K2Q
February 16, 2010 at 10:30 am
even that damned Tarantino thinks so!
February 16, 2010 at 3:27 pm
Kevembuangga:
The post wasn’t about paradoxes (at least I don’t think so). And one of the issues discussed in the Mises link was that modeling planets as point-masses is sometimes okay in physics, sometimes not.
John Sabotta, how about you explain to me what makes M&MM so great? And I agree that Kinsella has some dislikeable attributes.
February 16, 2010 at 8:40 pm
It’s Altman. First of all, that should be enough. But it’s probably Altman’s greatest achievement. I could talk about Altman’s indirect narrative, how you piece together what’s happening as you are plunged into one of his dense communities. Or I could talk about the expression on Julie Christie’s face, lost in opium dreams, or how a town is literally built around the viewer as he watches…there are too many great things in this film I BESEECH YOU SPEND THE LOUSY 17 DOLLARS OR SO AND BUY THIS FILM. (or rent it. Jeez, don’t they have any rental places in SF or wherever you live? Gahhh!)
MC CABE AND MRS MILLAR is in some ways what DEADWOOD aimed at. DEADWOOD missed but they made an honorable try. MC CABE AND MRS MILLER is cinema, great cinema, poetic and sad and beautiful, up there with Jean Renoir and Orson Welles. It’s the best Robert Altman, and we’ll never see his like again. WATCH IT.
February 16, 2010 at 8:42 pm
I remember Kinsella from NT, where he was a 24/7 fratboy-style asshole.
February 17, 2010 at 12:10 am
I’ve never seen an Altman movie, so it isn’t enough for me. I don’t live in SF, but the suburbs of Greater Chicagoland. I actually walked (I had lent my car) to Blockbuster this evening to see if they had it, but left emptyhanded.
Citizen Kane is a massively overrated movie. The Third Man and A Touch of Evil are alright though. That’s all the Welles I’ve seen. Haven’t seen any Renoir. At least I think so, the name is unfamiliar.
Did Kinsella have posting privileges at No Treason, or was he just a commenter? And what the hell is the deal with that site, Kennedy said he’d be restoring old content a couple years ago or something. If you have access you should start writing stuff there rather than relegating yourself to comments at other sites. At least at NT readers will expect it and not think “What’s the deal with that weirdo”?
February 23, 2010 at 1:54 pm
Well, this is in Chicago and they have it, although I am not sure if you can just rent things there like a regular place.
http://www.facetsmovies.com/user/movieBrowseByType.php
Kinsella was just a commenter. You’llk have to ask Kennedy about NT – I don’t know any more than you do. And I have no access there.
February 23, 2010 at 1:55 pm
Well, this is in Chicago and they have it, although I am not sure if you can just rent things there like a regular place.
http://www.facetsmovies.com/user/movieBrowseByType.php
Kinsella was just a commenter. You’ll have to ask Kennedy about NT – I don’t know any more than you do. And I have no access there.
February 23, 2010 at 8:25 pm
Facets says:
“All new members are eligible for a free trial membership. To avoid being charged when your free trial membership ends, simply cancel your membership before your trial is complete.”
JUST DO IT.
February 25, 2010 at 2:04 pm
I just became a reciprocal borrower of another library (I rented “The Selfish Gene”). They have the movie, but it is checked out at the moment.
I’ve asked Kennedy about NT. I don’t think he’s going to do anything with it, despite the “You’re not that lucky” notice.
February 17, 2010 at 8:47 am
The problem with the “physics diet” is that it typically does not work for stretches longer than 18 months.
Perhaps, its because people break down in their ability not to scratch that itch. However, one hypothesis, which I am sensitive to, is that individuals develop a tolerance to the euphoria horomones that Muller is describing and then the pain increases greatly.
What we do know is that their are a lot of hormones working against the physics diet. We don’t know exactly which ones produce the emotional effects that we observe: Excitement and enthusiasm at the beginning of a diet; Euphoria at the middle; Disillusionment at the end.
However, in something like 96% of cases, the results do come to an end.
March 11, 2011 at 12:04 am
[...] long as we’re talking India, a while back I linked to a free feature-length cartoon by Nina Paley called Sita Sings the Blues. It interleaves [...]